Medically reviewed by Dr. Kathan Talsania, Robotic Joint Replacement and Arthroscopic Surgeon, Health1 Super Speciality Hospitals, Shilaj, Ahmedabad | Last updated: 21 November 2026
8 things to check before choosing a knee surgeon
- Qualification. Look for M.S. or D.N.B. Orthopaedics, plus a fellowship in joint replacement (arthroplasty).
- Volume. Ask how many knee replacements the surgeon does each year. Practice matters.
- Honest advice. A good surgeon tells you when surgery can wait and offers physiotherapy, injections or partial replacement when suitable.
- Technology. Ask if robotic-assisted surgery is available and whether it suits you.
- Implant choice. Ask for the implant brand, expected life and warranty.
- Hospital infrastructure. NABH accreditation, laminar-flow operation theatres, ICU backup and physiotherapy team.
- Aftercare. Is a physiotherapy plan and follow-up schedule explained before surgery?
- Cost clarity. A written estimate with inclusions and exclusions.
Health1’s joint replacement and orthopaedic surgeons, Shilaj
| Surgeon | Qualifications | Focus | OPD |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dr. Kathan Talsania | MBBS, DNB (Chennai), DO (Mumbai), FIAA (Arthroplasty), FIAS (Arthroscopy), EFRA (Robotic Joint Replacement, The Netherlands). Reg. No. G-93411 | Robotic knee replacement; robotic partial knee replacement; robotic hip replacement; shoulder replacement; advanced arthroscopic surgeries (ligament injuries); revision joint replacement; infection surgeries; orthobiologics procedures | Monday to Saturday, 10 am to 6 pm |
| Dr. Harsh Raval | D.N.B. / M.S. Orthopaedics; fellowship in joint replacement and arthroscopy, sports medicine and shoulder | Knee, hip and shoulder replacement; robotic knee replacement | With prior appointment |
| Dr. Kalpesh Patel | M.S. Orthopaedics; fellowship in joint replacement; fellowship in shoulder surgery | Primary joint replacement (knee, hip, shoulder and elbow); revision joint replacement; robotic joint replacement surgery; complex trauma; joint preservation surgeries; deformity correction; minimal access surgeries | Tuesday and Thursday, 10 am to 12 pm |
| Dr. Ravi Prajapati | D.Ortho, M.S. Orthopaedics; fellowship in arthroplasty; Oxford-certified microplasty | Partial knee replacement; robotic-assisted knee and hip replacement | Monday and Friday, 10 am to 11 am |
| Dr. Nevil Gajera | M.S. Orthopaedics | Robotic joint replacement (Shilaj and Himmatnagar) | Monday and Friday, 6 pm to 7 pm |
Qualifications are as listed by each surgeon. OPD days and times can change, so please call to confirm before you visit.
Partial, total or robotic: which surgeon for which problem?
- Damage in one compartment of the knee: partial replacement may suit; ask a surgeon who does microplasty.
- Severe arthritis across the knee: total knee replacement, conventional or robotic.
- Sports injuries or ligament tears: a sports and arthroscopy specialist, who may avoid replacement entirely.
Why Health1 for knee replacement?
- Cuvis Joint robotic system with CT-based 3D planning
- NABH-accredited 330-bed hospital with 6 operation theatres and 18 ICU beds
- Walking with support within about 24 hours; stay 3 to 5 days
- Cashless with major insurers; CGHS and ECHS accepted
- Written cost estimate before surgery; see our robotic knee replacement cost guide
Read more: Arthroplasty and joint replacement at Health1 | Knee replacement with robotic precision.
Frequently asked questions
Who is the best knee replacement surgeon in Ahmedabad?
There is no single best surgeon for everyone. Choose by qualification, annual volume, advice quality and hospital support. Health1 lists its orthopaedic surgeons with qualifications above.
How many years of experience should a knee surgeon have?
A fellowship-trained surgeon with several years of regular joint replacement practice is a good benchmark.
Does the surgeon’s experience matter more than robotics?
Both matter. Robotics assists planning and accuracy but the surgeon decides the plan.
How do I book a consultation?
Call 079 6999 6999 or WhatsApp +91 97264 30202.
What should I bring to the first visit?
Previous X-rays or MRI, medicine list, and insurance details.
Can I get a second opinion?
Yes, and a good surgeon will welcome it.
Book a consultation
Health1 Super Speciality Hospitals, Shilaj Circle, S.P. Ring Road, Ahmedabad 380059. Call 079 6999 6999 or WhatsApp +91 97264 30202.
Related reading: Robotic knee replacement cost in Ahmedabad | Knee replacement surgery cost in Ahmedabad and India | Robotic knee replacement recovery timeline | Insurance companies